Trip Date: 2016 March & 2016 December
Field Trips #35 & 48
In the wake of the #Flint Water Crisis, Green Spiral Tours hosted two “Drinking Water Tours” to the water intake & treatment facility at Hog Hollow.
♥
♥
Most drinking water in America, including the city of Saint Louis, is managed by city municipalities, but the facility at Hog Hollow is operated by Missouri American Water, a private company.
♥
This facility provides water to the County, and thus about 80% of the region’s population. Here’s the good news and the bad news: we have an abundant supply of fresh clean water coming down the Missouri River, with no urgent threat, except for the serious situation at the the West Lake Landfill.
♥
♥
Saint Louis is defined by its rivers: the Missouri, Illinois and Mississippi Rivers meet just upstream from the city, and the Meramec River meets the Mississippi just south of the city. (Map courtesy of Great Rivers Greenway.)
♥
There are four water treatment facilities on the Missouri River and two on the Meramec; these six facilities supply all the drinking water to the Saint Louis region. In this day and age, everyone should know where their water comes from.
♥
About 80% of the region’s water comes from the Hog Hollow location, which is located near Chesterfield on the Missouri River: this facility feeds the County system which includes Saint Charles, Chesterfield, Webster Groves, Clayton, University City, and some parts of South Saint Louis. North Saint Louis, including Bridgeton, receives water mixed from both the Hog Hollow intake, and the water intake downstream at Charbonnier.
♥
The Missouri River is a fast, deep and fairly clean water source. In just eleven minutes, we can pull enough water out of the river to supply Saint Louis with a year’s worth of drinking water. Upstream are CAFO farms, industrial facilities, coal ash ponds, and a handful of nuke plants. The greatest water threat seems to be coming from “nonpoint” sources, including springtime nitrates, nutrient pollution from farm inputs, and industrial pollution like oil in the parking lot not coming from a pipe. Interestingly, large pipeline and chemical spills are a valid threat to clean water. All things considered, and relative to the rest of the country, Saint Louis has an abundant supply of fresh clean water, because we sit on the banks of a fast, clean flowing river. Here’s a nifty new tool that allows you to trace the Missouri river upstream: Slate.com
♥
If you’ve been following the Flint Water Crisis, you’ve been watching a catastrophic failure of government at every level, and a lot of finger pointing, as residents muddle through the days (and now years) on bottled water. Clearly, there is no easy fix in sight, and the story has turned a spotlight on aging infrastructure, corruption in government and weakening water regulations across the country. Here’s what Erin Brokovich had to say about Flint in March 2016, and the situation is getting worse: We Are All Flint
♥
Indeed, the Flint situation prompted the testing of local Saint Louis schools, and many of them popped up with lead troubles before school started in 2016. We all know that lead is damaging to young brains; it enters the water supply at the end point, where the house pipes meet the water main, for example, or where the drinking fountain meets the child. Lead is easily handled and not an issue for our water supply, per se. stl today Aug 2016
♥
For those just tuning in, we have a landfill loaded with a huge amount of nuclear waste in Saint Louis, and an unstoppable fire now within “hundreds of feet”, so there’s quite a lot of concern about radioactivity slipping into the drinking water supply. We know from the EPA that radioactivity is currently leaching into the groundwater, and that the groundwater under the landfill is now it’s own Superfund site. The groundwater is expected to seep into the Missouri River by ? 2030? If it’s not escaping into the river already.
♥
In March 2016, and again in December 2016, Green Spiral Tours took twenty reasonable and skeptical citizens on tours of the county facility at Hog Hollow, operated by Missouri American Water. This facility is located upstream from the landfill and the tours were informative and interesting. Our hosts were clearly professionals who take great pride in their work, and their transparency and candor were comforting. After both tours, Green Spiral participants had not big concerns, and pretty much agreed that the water supply from the County facility is mostly “safe”.
♥
Treating water for drinking is both a mechanical and chemical process. The water is drawn from the river, and then delivered by pipe to settling ponds. Chemically sticky positive ions, (like lime softening agents and carbon) are added, which cause large particles to clump together as colloidals, and sink to the bottom. This is how most of the heavy metals and radionuclides are removed from the water: they clump together and “settle” as sediment.
♥
♥
After leaving the settling ponds, the water is treated with chlorine and ammonia to kill microbes and pathogens, and then disturbed with aerating paddles, again to cause particles to knock together, clump, and fall to the bottom as sediment. Fluoride is added thanks to standards that has not been updated since 1950, and the young mothers were keen to know we have relatively more fluoride in Saint Louis (at .6mg/L) than other cities. (By the way, fluoride is a tiny molecule, which can be removed by reverse osmosis; the Lancet Journal has come out with this not so great news about the damaging effects of fluoride).
♥
In the final stage, water passes through a final filter (of anthracite, sand and pebbles) to remove the smallest particles before moving by pipe directly to the consumer. A dense network of pipes runs beneath the streets of Saint Louis, and the county has the ability to swap water with the city in order to handle the “Super Bowl Flush Rush” or the filling of too many swimming pools in early summer. The county water pipes interface with city water pipes somewhere around Skinker Blvd. As a final note: Missouri American Water adds extra carbon for taste, odor and color, and probably due to a high mineral county, Saint Louis wins awards for having great tasting water!
♥
While Missouri American Water operates the county water intake facility upstream from the landfill, the city of Saint Louis operates two intake facilities downstream from the landfill (and also one intake facility upstream from the landfill). Refer to the hand-drawn map. It’s all a little confusing, but the point is that the city and county can switch pipes and swap water at any time, and thus, we all drink the same water. The city has denied Green Spiral Tours a visit for security and safety reasons.
♥
This brings us down to test results, as well as the question of what is being tested, and what is not being tested for. For example, drinking water is not being tested for a variety of pharmaceuticals, which are known to be there. Safe Water Standards are set by the EPA and enforced by the State. Lots can be written about the EPA and the MDNR (Missouri Department of Natural Resources), and you could spend your life lobbying for clean water; thankfully, many people do. Bear in mind, for context, that the biggest threat to safe drinking water (by far) is e.coli, also known as “poop”.
♥
Here are some of the specific questions from our December group, along with answers: What about testing for specific radioactive isotopes associated with the West Lake Landfill, like radium 226 or thorium 230? Answer: The water tested in 2015 at the downstream Charbonnier facility revealed no detectable gross alpha or gross beta results. Water was also retrieved from the point where Cold Water Creek enters the Missouri River and no gross alpha or gross beta were detected. What about gylphosate? Answer: according to testing results, no glyphosate was detected in the raw water. What about radioactive particles leaking into the pipes? Answer: low emitter radioactive particles cannot penetrate pipes, and the water supply is a closed system. Which water system serves InBev and thus Budweiser Beer? Answer: County water, the Missouri American water treatment facility we visited at Hog Hollow. Question: How much of a problem are pipeline spills, as highlighted by Standing Rock situation, for example? Answer: Actually, kind of a problem. What about chloramines? Answer: Chlorine and chloramines seem to be a necessary evil. What about Chromium 6? Answer: Health standards are no feasibly attainable, but clean drinking water standards are met. Like I said, a person could spend a lifetime looking at test results and lobbying for clean water, and thankfully, many people do. Take a moment to look through the test results of your drinking water by entering your zipcode here: Water Quality Reports
♥
Testing for radionuclides is required every nine years by the EPA, but due to the unique situation at the West Lake Landfill, all four water facilities on the Missouri River were tested in 2015, and here are the results: http://www.amwater.com/ccr/STLSTC_rads.pdf
It is my understanding that the Missouri River is now being tested every year for radionuclides.
♥
Here are a few articles you may or may not want to read:
Erin Brokovich in Time Magazine: Feb 2016
Half of all US Rivers too polluted: The Wire 2013
MegaBanks: Buying up the World’s Water
DOE dumps radioactivity in Missouri River 1993: First Secret City
Water beyond America; Thank you Water.org: Water.org
Shut Down the Dakota Pipeline on the Missouri River: Before it Spills
Surprisingly, after long insisting that fracking does not contaminate groundwater, the EPA has now come out and said, “actually, it does”: Eco-Watch
♥
In the end, we all live downstream, and I encourage citizens to learn by doing, by organizing your own “Drinking Water” field trips.
♥
This is a good field trip for middle school students, high school students, and scout troops. Take about 12-20 people with you when you go, and make sure they are over age 10; names must be submitted for security reasons. Call the main number at Missouri American Water and ask for a tour: 314-469-6050. The tour takes about 2 hours and there is some driving out to the river. Go in March, when the leaves are just starting to turn green, or go in November, saving your best weather for planting in your garden or exploring the green world with kids. Tell them Green Spiral Tours sent you, and bring Saint Louis chocolates, or other suitable gifts when you go. Now here’s your homework:
♥
Visit your Drinking Water Treatment Facility: Create your own tour or follow Green Spiral Tours. Visiting a place in real life is entirely different than reading about it on the internet. You’ll be surprised at what you learn, and what sticks with you. Bring friends who will ask questions you would never think to ask. Take a moment to blog out or reflect on your experience to integrate the learning into your understanding of the way things work.
Use less fertilizer: Everything you put on your lawn, garden or driveway eventually ends up in the river, and over-fertilizing lawns is a major offender. Use native plants, which require far fewer fertilizers and almost no pesticides.
Salt is a problem – lobby your school or government to use salt wisely, and investigate new spray applications, which use a fraction of the amount of salt.
Clean up pet waste – Interestingly, dog poop creates an e.coli problem, so if you want to drink clean water, clean up after your dog.
Eat Local and Organic. Yep, it always seems to keep coming back to that. Farm policy matters a lot, because nitrogen and phosphorous inputs run off the land, into the wetlands and rivers, and ultimately into the Dead Zone in the Gulf of Mexico, (which is already quite large and getting larger). It’s sad, because the degraded habitat kills so many fish and animals.
Sign Petitions – Here’s a bunch of petitions you can sign from Food & Water Watch. Yes, petitions and phone calls do matter!
Comment below – put your questions below and I will write to Missouri American Water to see if they can be answered. Here’s a picture of me, Jessie, with an American bald eagle at the water intake facility next to the river.
♥
Green Spiral Tours
greenspiraltours.wordpress.com 